Skip to main content
replaced http://meta.mechanics.stackexchange.com/ with https://mechanics.meta.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

I was looking yesterday at a post. was specified in the tags. The question was about , so I tried to add the tag, only to realize that and are set as synonyms. I clicked on the tag to see the related questions and started looking through them. I can tell you from the variety of questions, this should not be a tag synonym. There are a 128 questions which cover everything, but only a small portion of them are diesel related. Looking at them just now, there are three tags which flow into , those being , , . IMHO, this really should not be. If I were to have been setting this up, the following would hold true:

  • and would be synonyms, covering petrol/gas engine related items
  • would be its own tag, covering all things related to diesel engine tech
  • would be its own tag, covering all thing related to fuel delivery

To me these are very different things. I think a perusal through the questions will tell you there is way too many questions lumped into which really doesn't make sense being there.

Just so you know I looked, there was this questionthis question posted here in the Meta where I think this all started. It was asked very early on in the Beta. I believe the outcome was a bit short sighted.

I was looking yesterday at a post. was specified in the tags. The question was about , so I tried to add the tag, only to realize that and are set as synonyms. I clicked on the tag to see the related questions and started looking through them. I can tell you from the variety of questions, this should not be a tag synonym. There are a 128 questions which cover everything, but only a small portion of them are diesel related. Looking at them just now, there are three tags which flow into , those being , , . IMHO, this really should not be. If I were to have been setting this up, the following would hold true:

  • and would be synonyms, covering petrol/gas engine related items
  • would be its own tag, covering all things related to diesel engine tech
  • would be its own tag, covering all thing related to fuel delivery

To me these are very different things. I think a perusal through the questions will tell you there is way too many questions lumped into which really doesn't make sense being there.

Just so you know I looked, there was this question posted here in the Meta where I think this all started. It was asked very early on in the Beta. I believe the outcome was a bit short sighted.

I was looking yesterday at a post. was specified in the tags. The question was about , so I tried to add the tag, only to realize that and are set as synonyms. I clicked on the tag to see the related questions and started looking through them. I can tell you from the variety of questions, this should not be a tag synonym. There are a 128 questions which cover everything, but only a small portion of them are diesel related. Looking at them just now, there are three tags which flow into , those being , , . IMHO, this really should not be. If I were to have been setting this up, the following would hold true:

  • and would be synonyms, covering petrol/gas engine related items
  • would be its own tag, covering all things related to diesel engine tech
  • would be its own tag, covering all thing related to fuel delivery

To me these are very different things. I think a perusal through the questions will tell you there is way too many questions lumped into which really doesn't make sense being there.

Just so you know I looked, there was this question posted here in the Meta where I think this all started. It was asked very early on in the Beta. I believe the outcome was a bit short sighted.

Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackMechanics/status/523557601767063552
Source Link

Should the Diesel tag and Fuel tag be Synonyms?

I was looking yesterday at a post. was specified in the tags. The question was about , so I tried to add the tag, only to realize that and are set as synonyms. I clicked on the tag to see the related questions and started looking through them. I can tell you from the variety of questions, this should not be a tag synonym. There are a 128 questions which cover everything, but only a small portion of them are diesel related. Looking at them just now, there are three tags which flow into , those being , , . IMHO, this really should not be. If I were to have been setting this up, the following would hold true:

  • and would be synonyms, covering petrol/gas engine related items
  • would be its own tag, covering all things related to diesel engine tech
  • would be its own tag, covering all thing related to fuel delivery

To me these are very different things. I think a perusal through the questions will tell you there is way too many questions lumped into which really doesn't make sense being there.

Just so you know I looked, there was this question posted here in the Meta where I think this all started. It was asked very early on in the Beta. I believe the outcome was a bit short sighted.